If there’s one thing that scares fashion bloggers more than spilling craft beer on their jeans, that thing would be finding a “MADE IN CHINA” label on a shirt that they have been eyeing all week.
For many, something being MADE IN CHINA is an automatic dealbreaker. “Made in China,” they feel, implies cheapness, the exploitation of labor laws, and inauthenticity. These are valid reasons to avoid some Chinese made clothing, but putting aside the question of how authentic it is to wear 1950s mining outfits in a 21st century city, in this article I will dispel the misconception that all Chinese made goods should be avoided by providing you with some amazing companies who are delivering quality products to consumers around the world.
Editor’s note: This article is an op-ed. The views expressed herein and in the video are the author’s and don’t necessarily reflect the views of Stridewise, LLC. Claims, assertions, opinions, and quotes have been sourced exclusively by the author.
[A pair of Sauce Zhan raw denim jeans]
You Snobby Denimheads
For starters, I want to talk about denim. Denimheads swear by their “made in the USA” or “made in Japan” jeans and anything else is considered second best.
(This is somewhat ironic after realizing that the same demographic flocks to RRL to buy Chinese made flannels every Autumn. What makes Chinese-made flannels more acceptable than Chinese-made jeans?)
My guess is that denimheads believe jeans to be a symbol of the “Americana image” that they want associated with their style. Though I have to admit that it is a lot cooler telling people my jeans are made in the States or Japan, having Chinese manufactured clothing doesn’t need to be something to be ashamed of!
Many of the brands that we see on the Chinese market, such as Sauce Zhan or Bob Dong or Red Cloud, have fantastic products. They often use Xinjiang cotton in the manufacturing process. This just means that they source their raw materials from in the Xinjiang region of China, and although not as popular as cotton from Zimbabwe or Texas, many experts in the textile industry would agree that Xinjiang cotton is worthy in its own right. First of all, it is a longer staple cotton which means the fibers are stronger and more durable. Long staple cotton tends to pill, wrinkle and fray less than cotton with a comparably shorter staple.
Now what about ethics? Are you not supporting cheap labor when you buy Chinese made goods? The short answer is that in some cases, yes, but like all short answers to complex questions, certain crucial information is omitted here.
While Chinese labor is cheap relative to American standards, the impacts of Chinese manufacturing can be transformative to families, and underdeveloped regions of millions of people. According to Chinese domestic reports, for example, recent surges in cotton demands had lifted 317,400 people in 331 villages out of poverty in 2017. That means that by buying a pair of Chinese denim, you can be helping families send their kid to school or helping them put meat on the dinner table.
Now, I am not saying that you are ending world poverty when buy “Made in China” however, I can say that it’s shortsighted to dismiss all Chinese-made goods. You can make a positive impact with my purchase.
[See all of Stridewise’s Japanese denim reviews here!]
The Meermin Chestnut Country Calf Boot
What About China-Made Boots?
The main concern that enthusiasts have with Chinese boots is that the quality may be inferior to America made footwear. I cannot speak for every Chinese manufactured shoe, but I can say with confidence that there are brands that are stellar with their quality, customer service and most important of all, transparency.
One brand, Meermin, that I’m sure many of us know about by now, actually manufactures part of their shoes in China. According to its founder Pepe Albaladejo:
the incentive of Chinese labor isn’t because its cheap. But because there is a well established expertise in China that can be readily employed.
Albaladejo himself has been training Chinese cordwainers for many years to the point where they are now masters of their trade. It is impractical for companies like Meermin to shift manufacturing to EU countries or the USA where the expertise isn’t available or where there is not sufficient demand for such jobs.
This is a little known fact about Chinese makers. many consumers just assume that its children at sweatshop that produces “Made in China” shoes. But you simply need to be discerning with which brands you patronize — there’s a difference between getting a pair of Meermin shoes and a pair off brand Puma sneakers.
[See my review of the Meermin Country Calf boot!]
[The famously well made Grant Stone Diesel boot — made in Xiamen, China]
Another brand that takes pride in their Chinese manufactured footwear is Grant Stone. Grant Stone not only tells you where their factories are located but also assures you that the owners have the same passion for well-made footwear as the consumers. One of the co-founders actually started his career as an intern at a shoe factory in Xiamen.
Co-founder Wyatt Gilmore told Stridewise,
When we started making samples with the best components available (thick leather insoles, cork, triple rib shank, leather heel counters, solid brass hardware, welts from Massachusetts, butyl outsoles) you realize that the quality of the product starts with the brand’s decision on where they need the price to land. If you use great materials and don’t cut corners, I’m sure there are plenty of manufacturers around the world who could make great product. Issues arise when brands are trying to be the lowest in the market and spec the product accordingly, cutting costs on components. This is what nearly everyone was doing back in the 90s when moving production to China: spec’ing the cheapest components possible to lower the price and grow volume.
In just the last 5 years, China’s labor pool is now pricing itself out of the ‘least expensive labor’ category. Especially around the coastal areas where cost of living has sky rocketed (we have a Starbucks walking distance from our factory). Products that include more in depth manufacturing are having a difficult time leaving even with the higher wages because these factories are excellent at producing.
We hope to continue growing in this direction, focussing on the quality putting the volume aside.
Companies like Meermin and Grant Stone do not just invest in themselves, but they invest in the local people. It is this very reason that helps them stand in the “Made in China” shoe market. When you have a positive relationship with your factories, the people are more inclined to give you a quality product. This is a stark difference from companies who stamp “Made in Italy” on their products but secretly employ Chinese workers who were moved from a Chinese factory to an Italian one now. I am willing to bet that it crossed no one’s mind that the person who welted their Gucci bluchers is Chinese and not a middle age Italian working in his suit at his private studio.
[See our Grant Stone Diesel Boot review!]
[Iron Boots, another high quality, China-based boot brand]
Its Okay To Buy Chinese
In conclusion, it is okay to buy Chinese. Not all Chinese products are cheap and unethically made. As mentioned above, there are a lot of brands that consumers have been sleeping on and should wake up to.
Besides, it’s 2019. Being prejudiced to things from other countries is so last year.
Humphrey Tsui
Latest posts by Humphrey Tsui (see all)
- Are Dievier’s Nomads the Most Affordable Moc Toe Boots? - March 6, 2023
- The 10 Best Leather Sneakers for Men | Minimalist, Low Profile, Dressy Sneaks - February 24, 2023
- Thursday Vanguard vs Captain | Is One Boot Better for Your Needs? - February 2, 2023
I am with you on a lot of points…strictly for the reason that made in USA for me means cut corners, using cheaper materials to make more money…take for instance red wing or any other ” made in usa ” boots…most of the materials used are cheap…also most made in usa is made in usa with imported materials which is an exclamation mark by itself
Transparency in the MiUSA market needs to be better.
To bad Nazi Germany isn’t around, we could buy there goods to.
Nazi Germany is gone. There are still Nazis everywhere. Here in the USA and over the pond. Don’t buy from people who show those views. You can, however, buy from family own operations that don’t show any allegiance to those people.
I hear what you are saying but I could not disagree more. Its china or Italy that’s the problem. Made anywhere but here means encouraging a competing industry and putting Americans out of work. If you don’t feel Red wings or Aldens or Allen Edmonds or Trumans are up to your standards…don’t buy them. Better yet, call them and tell them to do better. I did.
Why would I support United Statesian manufacturers when I can support German, Croatian, Spanish and other companies who offer better quality for my money and aren’t a brutal regime focused on oppressing the local population?
Right, buy it from China so they can build more islands in the international waters of the South China Sea, or find clandestine operations to steal more US intellectual property. What’s wrong with that?
Involuntary work camps, lack of citizen freedom and regime it’s the reason people should ditch the china. Not to mention buyout of tech companies all around the world which leads to monopoly by a totalitaristic country
Ain’t nobody complain about Mass Surveillance, Police Brutality, Regime Changing Wars when they buy a pair of Red Wings.
Are you directly supporting Mass Surveillance, Police Brutality, Regime Changing Wars when you buy American goods?
You realize the USA has the largest prison population in the world, and the rest of us aren’t exactly free, given the ridiculous limits on expression and the lack of social welfare and health programs for the working poor. Plus, most prisoners in the US are in prison for stupid things like cannabis possession, and the US employs prison labor (involuntary work camps) and pays them slave wages.
In many ways, people in China are more free than we are in the USA. At least there, no one is homeless, and everyone has access to healthcare and social welfare programs. Plus, the Chinese government is much more responsive to its citizens’ needs than the US government is.
Okay they can’t shift from China to EU or USA but what about other Asian countries like India, Taiwan or Indonesia?